The Rebbitzen is right, of course!
The Torah does not give us, as individuals, the right to do whatever we want wherever we want.
Editor’s note: We asked two people to write articles on why a frum Jew should or should not wear a mask outdoors (and possibly indoors). We asked both of them not to dispute the available scientific data as neither author is a medical doctor or scientist.
* * * * *
Be A Mench, Wear A Mask
By Shani Bechhofer, PhD
We are living in hyper-partisan times. So many aspects of our lives have been swallowed up by politics and become divisive “issues.” One such issue is wearing masks to contain the spread of Covid-19. People tend to regard masks as symbols of allegiances, loyalties, philosophies, and psychological states.
This is most unfortunate. As Orthodox Jews, we should be able to disentangle Torah values from the morass of American political argumentation and rise above the nasty fray. I have been asked to present some arguments for wearing masks in public. Here are a few:
- Nizkei shecheinim: There are numerous halachos pertaining to public safety. To name a few: We are obligated to plant trees away from wells, plant mustard away from others’ beehives, construct thick ceilings for downstairs tenants, not pile thorns on public walkways, and not drain refuse into a public thoroughfare.
The Torah does not give us, as individuals, the right to do whatever we want wherever we want. Each of us plays a role in maintaining a good environment for the public.
- Ke’she’ani la’atzmi, mah ani: Wearing a mask during a pandemic that has already killed hundreds of Jews and hundreds of thousands of Americans – and brought debilitating suffering upon many more – is an act of chesed towards others, protecting them from the droplets we exhale.
Remember, Covid-19 can be a terrible affliction, whether or not one dies from it, r”l. There is no sure way to predict how intensely it will affect a person. There is no known cure, and no vaccine is currently available. Its possible long-term effects on the brain, the lungs, and the heart are not yet known. You can do your part to stop it in its tracks.
- Wearing a mask in public also gives chizuk to others who feel self-conscious about wearing one. Even if you know you aren’t contagious – perhaps you just took an antibody test – your choice to wear a mask is indeed contagious! By wearing a mask, we remind those who see us to be careful. Do it for altruistic reasons. Olam chesed yibaneh.
- Al haTorah, v’al ha’avodah, v’al gemillus chassadim: Universal mask wearing is the best way to prevent the outbreaks that lead to lockdowns and shutdowns. If we want to keep shuls and yeshivos open, we need a way to make sure contagious people don’t inadvertently spread through the community.
Covid-19 is often spread by people who don’t know they are infected because they have no symptoms. Fortunately, studies have been finding that masks greatly reduce the spread of the virus if a high enough percentage of the population wears them consistently.
N95 masks are ideal, but even homemade masks reduce the risk in the population overall. Wearing a mask is a statement in support of prioritizing limud haTorah and tefillah betzibur. If we want the voices of tinokos shel beis rabban to be heard in our local schools, chedarim, and Bais Yaakovs, we have to commit to doing whatever is needed to keep the virus contained.
- Mipnei darchei shalom: We don’t live in isolation. Outsiders are often outraged when religious communities defy policies meant to protect the general public. When we act as if we prioritize our own comfort over the safety of others, it damages our relationships with our fellow Americans.
Our own sincere beliefs about the relative danger of the virus or about the efficacy of masks or about the motives of government officials in requiring us to wear them – none of this is known to a passerby, a housekeeper, a grocery store cashier, or a fellow shopper. A recent Pew Research survey found that 71 percent of American adults believe people in their own community should wear a mask “always” or “most of the time” when they go to public places where they may be near others.
Only 12 percent chose “rarely” or “never.” So bear in mind that what may make perfect sense to you actually appears as gross insensitivity, poor hygiene, and a threat to public health to most Americans.
- Keep it consistent and uncomplicated. Wear your mask outside too unless you are in an isolated area. Even if you intend to stay six feet away from friends outdoors, you should wear it as it’s getting harder to stay disciplined after all these months.
- Vehadarta pnei zaken: We believe in the sanctity of life and honoring the elderly. How sad to hear some in our communities echoing foreign anti-Torah ideas that treat older people as expendable, ch”v! When young people or those unconcerned about catching the virus don’t wear a mask, not only are they are failing to protect those who are vulnerable; they are communicating a lack of caring.
Consider a school in which an older morah wears a mask every day, but the younger moros almost never wear masks. The younger moros are communicating a complete lack of kavod and chesed towards the more senior morah, who is wearing the mask because she wants to be safe. I can’t think of a more extreme lack of chesed and expression of chutzpah than this.
- Shenasan mei’chachmaso l’basar v’dam: Our tradition is not anti-rational or anti-expertise. There is nothing heretical about the science of particle spreading. A wise person knows the limits of his own knowledge.
“I’m not a scientist or an engineer, but I do have a degree in common sense,” one anti-masker wrote online, launching an epic “take-down” of the “expert” Dr. Fauci. Well, that’s terrific, I thought. I’m impressed with your ability to spot the very obvious logical flaws that Dr. Fauci was unable to notice.
And if the conclusions you draw from the info you happened to come across turn out to have been wrong, will your degree enable you to guide my treatment if I, ch”v, catch the virus from you?
- Ilmalei morah shel malchus, ish es rei’eihu chayim bela’o: It’s the law. New York State currently requires us to wear a mask in public except outdoors when one can maintain a distance of at least six feet from all other people.
It is generally our obligation – as Americans and Jews – to obey the law. This applies whether or not we agree with, approve of, or like it. We may certainly try to lobby, advocate, or even sue to change unjust or unwise laws; but until as long as they are on the books, we are bound by them.
If you choose to disobey the law – even on principle – you must be willing to accept the consequences. That is how civil disobedience works. It is a strategy for making change, not permission to do whatever you want and get angry when held accountable.
The rule of law protects us from chaos and violence. If it weren’t for “mora shel malchus,” people would swallow one another alive, says Pirkei Avos. We can also be pretty confident that a breakdown of the rule of wouldn’t be “good for the Jews.”
We’re supposed to be rachmonim, bayshonim, and gomlei chassadim. Wearing a mask around other people is an expression of each of these traits. Brazenly violating safety rules and putting others at risk in order to be comfortable or to express a political opinion is an indulgence that does not reflect the middos expected of a Jew.
* * * * *
Mask Mandates Are Part Of An Anti-Jewish Assault
By Rabbi Michoel Green
There is no halachic obligation for a healthy person to wear a mask outdoors – or anywhere else for that matter (with very few exceptions, like in surgery rooms).
The law of “Do not stand over your brother’s blood” is not relevant since the actual risk of not wearing a mask is negligible from a halachic point of view. Alleged statistical risks are not a factor in halacha with regards to prevention. For example, halacha prohibits killing a spider on Shabbos even though there is a 1 in 1,000 chance that someone might be at mortal risk if the spider falls into his food (Shulchan Aruch HaRav 316:23).
The fact that doctors recommend that the population at large wear masks is irrelevant. The principle that “authority was granted to a healer to heal” was stated only regarding a physician who has clinically evaluated an individual patient – not regarding physicians making public policy.
Furthermore, the authority conferred upon doctors is only to heal. With regards to preventative measures, doctors have a vote, but not a veto (this opinion attributed to Rabbi Chaim Brisker). While in some cases it might be wise to heed a doctor’s advice, it is in no way obligatory (see Igros Moshe, Choshen Mishpat 2:76).
One may ask: Even if it’s not obligatory, isn’t it still advisable to heed the recommendation of doctors in regards to preventing llness?
The answer is that it is advisable if the advice is (a) for your own personal benefit; (b) based on empirical evidence; (c) not contested by other expert physicians; and (d) carries no risks of its own.
Doctors’ advice on mask-wearing, though, doesn’t meet any of these four criteria:
(a) Masks are promoted as a means to protect the community – not wearers – most of whom are at low-risk of being harmed by the virus in any case;
(b) There’s no direct evidence that asymptomatic transmission is even a major factor in this disease or that masks prevent transmission in such cases. The belief that they do is based on statistical models, which have no legitimacy in halacha;
(c) There are plenty of medical experts who oppose mask-wearing for healthy individuals (see www.americasfrontlinedoctors.com, for example).
(d) Wearing a mask entails risks that are well-documented by OSHA and numerous expert physicians.
Consequently, the current mask policy is not halachically advisable except possibly for individuals at heightened risk, for whom it might be advisable – although not obligatory – to wear an N-95 mask that might afford them some sort of protection.
In addition to the above considerations, there are actually halachic problems with wearing a mask:
1) It’s inappropriate to stand before a king wearing a mask on one’s face. How much more so to stand before the King of Kings and pray. (See the recent teshuvah by Rabbi Moshe Shternbuch on this topic.)
2) One may not wear a mask while teaching or learning Torah (see Exodus 34:35; Torah Shleimah, vol. 21, pages 179 and 183; Pele Yoetz 341, based on Isaiah 30:20, “Your eyes shall behold your teachers”; and Yahel Ohr on Tehillim 39:7).
3) Wearing masks is not a Jewish practice. Masks are never mentioned in Tanach and only appear in halacha in regards to frightening children. Masks are commonplace in pagan worship and are of polytheistic origin.
There are numerous hashkafic problems with wearing a mask as well:
1) According to Kabbalah, one’s mouth and nose should never be covered. Rabbi Moses Cordovero, for example, writes in Tomer Devorah that one’s mouth and nose should always remain uncovered in resemblance of the Divine.
2) Masks ominously symbolize idolatry, division, and estrangement from G-d (see the Ohr HaChaim on Leviticus 19:4).
3) A human face is tzelem Elokim, a reflection of the divine face. Placing any barrier over it obscures this G-dly distinction and reduces a human being to a faceless droid.
4) Hiding one’s face is reminiscent of G-d hiding His face from us.
It should also be noted that masks are just one element of a broader government Covid-19 policy. This policy in its entirety constitutes an egregious attack on Judaism, akin to a g’zeiras shmad.
According to this policy, religion is “non-essential.” Hundreds of passengers may sit in close contact for a 12-hour flight, but houses of worship may only have 10 worshippers. Black Lives Matter protesters are allowed to congregate and riot by the thousands, but Jews have been banned from communal prayer, visiting the sick, escorting the dead, rejoicing with a bride and groom, and learning Torah in public.
These activities are essential in Judaism and ought to be observed publicly with many participants. Policies that ban or greatly restrict these activities do not comport with our faith.
Our Sages declared that the entire world exists solely in the merit of the breath of children chanting words of Torah. Children studying Torah is an even higher priority than constructing the Beit Hamikdash! Jerusalem was destroyed because children were prevented from attending yeshiva.
A century ago, in the Soviet Union, religion was declared “non-essential.” The Soviets banned all forms of public religion. Jews were permitted to practice Judaism in their homes but not in groups. Yeshivos, synagogues, and houses of study were shut down. Nearly everyone complied. Most rabbis were silent.
One Jew refused to comply. Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn of Lubavitch dared to defy the dictates of the Soviet regime and organized underground yeshivos and inspired his adherents to do the same.
He was arrested and incarcerated. On the day he was released from prison, he declared, “We must proclaim openly and before all that any matter affecting the Jewish religion, Torah, and its mitzvos and customs is not subject to the coercion of others. No one can impose his belief upon us, nor coerce us to conduct ourselves contrary to our beliefs.”
Even those who recognize an element of statistical pikuach nefesh with regards to Covid-19 guidelines should consider the words of the Chazon Ish: “Pikuach nefesh overrides the entire Torah, but it does not uproot the entire Torah.”
A policy that interferes with a Jewish child’s access to a Torah education dangerously seeks to uproot the entire Torah. It cannot be tolerated, even if the policy purports to be about pikuach nefesh.
Jews ought to reject Covid-19 policies that are not supported by halacha.
Finally, chillul Hashem is not a factor here since there is no objective value that obligates a Jew to wear a mask in the first place. The fact that there is a prevalent societal attitude that healthy people who don’t wear masks are somehow perpetuating a pandemic is irrelevant. Judaism doesn’t kowtow to popular opinion or policies that have no actual merit in halacha.
The fact that a Jew shows his face in public does not constitute a chillul Hashem by any halachic definition. If some non-Jews look askance at those who flaunt an unjust state policy, that’s their problem.
In fact, by not wearing a mask in public, one is making a kiddush Hashem. A proud Jew doesn’t bow before dictates of an unjust state policy that perilously threatens the existence of our people. There is absolutely nothing shameful about showing your tzelem Elokim.
I believe the root of the disagreement lies in a basic premise which could be summarized in the following question: "Does the vast majority of people wearing masks save hundreds of thousands of lives?"
ReplyDeleteI think Dr. Bechhofer would say yes and Rabbi. Green would say no. And based on their understanding of the affectiveness of masks they draw their conclusions.
So I believe if agreement is to be reached a meta analysis of the current research should be done.
Also to Rabbi Green it's my understanding that woman including Jewish women in the times of the Tanach may have covered their faces examples such as Tamar and Rochel moshe also wearing a mask after returning of har Sinai. And the masks worn to prevent the spread of desease have nothing to do with avoda zara and have a specific stated purpose (whether affective or not). But I think the bottom line is if wearing masks truly does save hundreds of thousands of lives I think you'd agree that would overrides any of your other halachic and hashkafic considerations you raised.
To Dr. Bechhofer I also have some comments. I do wonder how accurate the 200,000 death number is. Firstly it includes those with comorbidities such as cancer. So the question is did Covid cause the death or was it something else in each case? Also early on there wasn't testing and my understanding is that people showing any symptoms were often said to have died of Covid when they may have had the flu or something else. Further more I've heard that hospitals get money for cases or deaths from covid which may also skew the numbers. Also early on there ws little known a out how to treat it and therefore anymore may have died than would die going forward. Also early on there were reports of patience be neglected and not fed adequately because staff were sacred to get the virus. So these are all things that I think have to be looked at. Further more we must also not only consider the cost of not doing anything but also the cost of our actions. For example what are the consequences of having everyone wear masks socially, on education on child development, people's frustration, our rights and freedoms. And the same for the affects of lockdowns on mental health, suicide, domestic violence, social isolation, job loss, business closures, economy etc.
I passed your comment along to the Rebbitzen.
DeleteI wonder what the "consequences" of mask-wearing are. I've been teaching 3 year olds with a mask for weeks, it does make it a little difficult to be hear and understood properly, but honestly it can be done and in the end you forget about it. It's inconvenient, but it's not an obstacle to anything. As to out "rights and freedom" to potentially endanger people for the sake of our little comfort...
DeleteIf one year ago I told you that the government will mandate that all first graders will have to wear masks all day in school for two years and stay 6 feet away from each other at all times you would probably say I'm crazy. We don't know what affect that will have on childrens development socially and mentally. It's something worth considering. And the other consideration is how many lives are being saved. I think for many people the answer to both those questions is I don't know. Also freedom is a value of tremendous significance. The details of which would take time to explain but it's not something to just be dismissed so easily. People are buying told they don't have a right to run their business, meet with people, walk outside without a mask in some cases. These things are not to be taken for granted and must be weighed as an important consideration.
DeleteThe Rebbitzen's response is at https://rygb.blogspot.com/2020/11/follow-up-on-pointcounterpoint-to-mask.html
DeleteThe drivel espoused by the likes of Rabbi Green is beyond description. The best way I've seen to understand how people can be convinced of this illogical tripe was said by noted psychologist Dr. David Lieberman - it's likely a survival mechanism or reflex to help them deal with the fact that they are unable to cope with their fear of the pandemic. Instead of acknowledging their own mortality and risk of illness, they reject any evidence that forces them to consider the possibility that they may become victims of something they cannot completely control.
ReplyDeleteTo be blunt, Rabbi Green, and others like him, are to be pitied for their inability to deal with this crisis in an objectively logical manner. Hashem Ye'rachem