Emunah: Reb Elchonon's Approach part 3

8G Sunday Zoom Shiur - November 01

VIEW RECORDING - 27 mins (No highlights)

Meeting Purpose

To explore the motivations behind belief and the role of secular knowledge in faith.

Key Takeaways

• Belief is simple; denial is often self-serving. People deny God to avoid the "yoke" of religious obligation, preferring personal freedom over divine will.
• Judaism's goal is heroism, not happiness. Its 365 negative commandments (vs. 248 positive) are a rigorous training regimen to build character, not to maximize comfort.
• Motivation is paramount for good deeds. Actions done to fulfill a divine command are superior to those done for personal satisfaction, as the latter is self-worship.
• Secular knowledge is essential for faith. Understanding science and history reveals God's greatness in creation, making it a critical component of Torah study.

Topics

The Motivation for Belief vs. Denial

• Denial of God is often a rationalization to avoid the "yoke" of religious obligation.
• This aligns with Rabbi Soloveitchik's view that Judaism's goal is heroism, not happiness.
  • Rationale: The rigorous training required to become a hero (e.g., an athlete) necessitates self-discipline and deprivation.
  • Evidence: The 365 negative commandments (vs. 248 positive) are a training regimen to build character, not to maximize comfort.

The Superiority of Commanded Actions

• The Rambam states that non-Jews are considered righteous only if their good deeds are performed because they know God commanded them.
  • Rationale: This demonstrates submission to a creator, not just personal preference.
  • Critique: Actions done for personal satisfaction are self-worship, as motivation is tied to feeling good, not to what is objectively right.
• Chazal's Principle: "One who is commanded and does is greater than one who is not commanded and does."
  • Tosafot's Explanation: The commanded person feels greater anxiety about fulfilling their duty, making their action more precious.
  • Example: A man's reward for shaking a lulav is greater than a woman's, as he is commanded and she is volunteering.

Secular Knowledge as a Path to Faith

• Secular knowledge (science, history) is essential for appreciating God's creation.
• The Vilna Gaon's Example:
  • Mastered all secular knowledge except medicine.
  • Rationale: Feared that practicing medicine would distract from Torah study.
  • Key Insight: Stated that music theory is the most important secular subject for understanding Torah.

 

Torah Im Derech Eretz: Rabbi Dr Isaac Breuer's Moriah pt 15: Torah Judicial, Legislative, Executive

Moriah by Rabbi Dr Isaac Breuer

Meeting Purpose

To define the Jewish people's national mission and the nature of the "State of Torah."

Key Takeaways

• The "State of Torah" (Medinat HaTorah) is the ultimate goal. It's a unique union of the Nation of Torah (Am HaTorah) and the Land of Torah (Eretz HaTorah), where God's will is the sole sovereign authority.
• The mission is societal, not just individual. While individual perfection is possible, the Jewish people's purpose is to act as a nation in history, influencing the world through a "spiritual conquest" of the land.
• The State of Torah is a "divine protest" against human rebellion. It functions as a model society where God's will is the only authority, contrasting with the "curse of diplomacy" and the power struggles of other nations.
• God holds all three branches of government. The state's constitution is defined by the verse, "Hashem is our Judge, Hashem is our Lawgiver, Hashem is our King," with human leaders serving only as His agents.

Topics

The National Mission: From Desert to History

• Desert vs. Land: The desert was a place for individual perfection, but the national mission requires a historic life in Eretz Yisrael.
• Societal Purpose: Judaism's place is in human history, not isolation.
  • Why: Only a nation can fully actualize the Torah's potential from theory to practice.
  • Avraham's Precedent: His concern for Sodom and Gomorrah indicates a national responsibility for the world, a task too large for most individuals.
• "Divine Protest": The Jewish people's role is to be a divine protest against human rebellion.
  • Goal: A "spiritual conquest" of the land, not just physical occupation.
  • Why Eretz Yisrael: Its location at the crossroads of continents (Asia, Africa, Europe) forces interaction, preventing isolation.

The "State of Torah" (Medinat HaTorah)

• Three Unities: The state is the product of three unities:
  1. Unity of Name (Ichud Shem): The Nation of Torah (Am HaTorah).
  2. Unity of Place (Ichud Kan): The Land of Torah (Eretz HaTorah).
  3. Unity of Purpose: God's will (Ratzon Hashem), which governs the nation in the land.
• Distinction from Medinat Yisrael: The current State of Israel is not a Medinat HaTorah because its definition of Judaism is not based on Torah.
• Unique Structure: Unlike other nations where the people are absorbed by the state, the Nation and Land of Torah are distinct, eternal entities.
  • Analogy: A marriage, where two separate partners unite to fulfill a shared destiny.
  • Significance: The state is an expression of Judaism, but Judaism itself exists independently of the state.

The Constitution of the State of Torah

• Core Principle: The state's constitution is defined by the verse, "Hashem is our Judge, Hashem is our Lawgiver, Hashem is our King."
• Three Branches of Government: God holds all three authorities:
  • Judge (Shoftenu): Judicial branch.
  • Lawgiver (Mekokainu): Legislative branch.
  • King (Malkenu): Executive branch.
• Contrast with Other Nations:
  • No "Brazen Nation": No power struggles between states.
  • No "Curse of Diplomacy": No language used to conceal thought.
  • No Human Sovereignty: Only God's will rules, with human leaders acting as His agents.
• Justice for the Poor: The state's laws are specifically designed to protect the impoverished and save them from oppression.

 

Yaakov and Esav's Blessings, Rivka's Prophecy, Avraham Avinu's Prayer for Sodom - Uganda Shiur

I merged two segments into one. That is why there are two summaries below:

Uganda Shiur - October 29 part 1

Key Takeaways

• Winning Defined by Purpose: Judaism defines "winning" as fulfilling one's divine purpose, not achieving worldly success. This explains why Esau, focused on this world, received a longer, more detailed blessing than Jacob.
• Multiple Paths to Truth: God's plan includes multiple valid paths, requiring different blessings tailored to each individual's unique purpose.
• Prophecy Overrules Law: Rivka's actions were justified by a direct prophecy, which overrides standard law. For non-prophetic dilemmas, consult a wise authority or, if time is critical, make a thoughtful decision based on the larger picture.
• Human Action Drives Divine Mercy: God limits His direct intervention (tzimtzum) to empower humanity. Prayer (tefillah) is the primary tool for humans to activate divine mercy and improve the world.

Topics

Question 1: Yaakov & Esau's Relationship

• Question: How does the relationship challenge the idea of clear winners and losers?
• Answer: The concept of "winning" differs fundamentally.
  • Esau: Worldly success (business, physical comfort).
    • His longer, more detailed blessing reflects this focus.
    • Rejected the firstborn's spiritual duties (e.g., bringing sacrifices) as too risky for his worldly goals.
  • Yaakov: Fulfilling divine will and connecting with God.
    • His shorter blessing reflects this spiritual focus.
    • Worldly life is a tool for this purpose; spiritual success is possible even with worldly loss.

Question 2: Multiple Blessings

• Question: What do two different blessings reveal about God's plan?
• Answer: God's plan includes "multiple truths" and different paths for different people.
  • Source: A rabbinic teaching that the Torah has 49 ways to be good and 49 ways to be bad.
  • Application: Each person has a unique purpose and requires a tailored blessing to achieve it.
  • Example: Wealth can be a blessing or a curse, depending on how it's used.

Question 3: Rivka's Actions

• Question: Did Rivka do the right thing by having Yaakov "steal" the blessings?
• Answer: Yes, because she acted on a direct prophecy.
  • Principle: A direct divine command overrides standard law (e.g., Abraham's sacrifice of Isaac).
  • Context: Yaakov trusted her because he knew she received prophetic messages.
• General Principle for Dilemmas:
  • 1. Consult: Seek guidance from a wise authority (rabbi, elder).
  • 2. Decide: If time is critical, make a thoughtful decision based on the larger picture.
    • Example: Stealing medicine to save a life, where the value of life overrides the prohibition on theft.

Parashat Vayeira: Sodom & Gomorrah

• Context: Abraham's negotiation with God to save Sodom and Gomorrah for the sake of 50, then 45, down to 10 righteous people.
• Question: Why did God need Abraham to plead?
• Answer: God limits His direct intervention (tzimtzum) to empower humanity.
• Rationale: God created a world where humans are responsible for its moral direction.
• Mechanism: Prayer (tefillah) is the primary tool for humans to activate divine mercy.
• Nature of Prayer: Can be "chutzpahic" (bold, brazen) because God wants humans to take charge.

Uganda Shiur - October 29 part 2

Meeting Purpose

To explain the role of prayer in human-divine interaction.

Key Takeaways

• Prayer as Human Agency: Prayer is the primary tool for human agency, activating divine intervention in a world where God has delegated responsibility to people.
• Avraham's "Chutzpah": Avraham's bold negotiation for Sdom (Sodom) exemplified a child-like "chutzpah," an acceptable directness with God driven by a selfless desire to save people.
• Divine Intervention: God's direct intervention is rare (e.g., Sdom, Ninveh), serving as a clear warning for humanity to act righteously.
• Avraham's Trials: Avraham self-circumcised and was passive during the Pharaoh incident; God and Sarah's prayer, not Avraham's action, secured his wife's return.

Topics

The Purpose of Prayer

• Core Principle: God delegated world management to humanity, making prayer the primary tool to activate divine intervention.
• Rationale: This model solves the paradox of prayer (why ask an omniscient God for help?) by establishing it as the required human action to "get the ball rolling."
• Historical Context:
  • The power of prayer has diminished since the time of the great tzaddikim.
  • Direct divine intervention is rare, serving as a warning (e.g., Sdom, Ninveh).
  • After the Second Temple, God stopped sending direct messages, making human action and prayer the sole drivers of change.

Avraham's Trials & Prayer

• Self-Circumcision: Avraham performed the circumcision himself, a courageous act.
• Pharaoh Incident:
  • Context: During a famine in Mizraim (Egypt), Avraham presented Sarah as his sister to protect himself.
  • Outcome: Pharaoh took Sarah, but God intervened directly, sending a plague to secure her return.
  • Significance: Avraham was passive; God and Sarah's prayer, not Avraham's action, resolved the crisis.

Rischa D'Araisa Season 14 Episode 9: Glory Beyond the Fire: The French Rishonim and The Talmudic Mind

 This podcast episode is dedicated to the memory of Dr. Jerry Noble a"h

Rischa D'Araisa Season 14 Episode 9:

Glory Beyond the Fire:

The French Rishonim and The Talmudic Mind

https://listen.jewishpodcasts.fm/yeshivaofnewark/126924

Emunah: Reb Elchonon's Approach part 2

8G Sunday Zoom Shiur - October 25

Meeting Purpose

To explore the psychological roots of disbelief and the nature of divine existence.

Key Takeaways

• God exists outside of time, which is a creation. This makes the question "Who created God?" invalid, as "before" is a concept that only applies within the created universe.
• Disbelief is often a rationalization of desire, not a logical conclusion. People create belief systems to justify forbidden actions or claim sole credit for their accomplishments.
• The mitzvah of emunah (belief) is a command to maintain intellectual honesty by not letting personal desires distort one's perception of truth.
• A logical person, observing the world's complexity, must seek its purpose and "instruction manual" (Torah), making belief a universal responsibility.

Topics

The Nature of Divine Existence

• Problem: If everything needs a creator, who created God?
• Solution (Rambam): God created time itself and exists outside of it.
  • "Before" is a concept that begins with the universe's creation.
  • From God's perspective, all time (past, present, future) occurs simultaneously.
  • Analogy: A split-screen TV shows two places at once; God's perspective collapses time similarly.
• Implication: Past and future events have a present impact.
  • Akeidas Yitzchak: Its merit is remembered annually because it is eternally present to God.
  • Rosh Chodesh: Celebrates a future event (universal pilgrimage to Jerusalem), showing the future's influence on the present.

The Problem of Disbelief

• Question: How can great thinkers deny God?
• Answer: Disbelief is often a rationalization of desire (negiyah), not a logical conclusion.
  • Analogy (Dubna Magid): An archer shoots an arrow, then draws the bullseye around it.
    • People often decide what they want → then create a belief system to justify it.
  • Example: A desire for forbidden pleasures (e.g., ham) can lead one to deny the Torah to remove the prohibition.
• Two Primary Motivations for Disbelief:
  1. Justifying Forbidden Pleasures: Denying God removes the authority behind prohibitions.
  2. Claiming Sole Credit: Denying God allows one to attribute accomplishments solely to oneself, not divine help (siata d'Shemaya).

The Universal Obligation to Believe

• Core Principle: The world's complexity is a clear witness to a Creator.
• Logical Progression for Any Rational Person:
  1. Observe: The world is complex and designed.
  2. Deduce: It must have a designer.
  3. Ask: What is the designer's purpose?
  4. Seek: The "instruction manual" for this complex creation.
  5. Discover: The Torah, which the Jewish people claim is that manual.
• The Mitzvah of Emunah:
  • It is a command to maintain intellectual honesty by not letting personal desires distort one's perception of truth.
  • With a clear mind, belief in God and Torah is a natural, compelling conclusion.

Q&A: Specific Challenges to Belief

• Question: Why is eiver min ha-chai (eating a limb from a live animal) forbidden for non-Jews?
• Answer: It's one of the Seven Noahide Laws, which establish a just society.
  • This specific prohibition bans extreme cruelty, which fosters violence and can lead to cruelty toward humans.
• Question: How can a Holocaust survivor be expected to believe in God?
• Answer: Anger or questions directed at God are not a lack of emunah (belief).
  • One can believe God exists while struggling with His actions, similar to being angry at a parent or sibling.
  • The existence of legitimate questions does not negate the reality of God's existence.

Next Steps

• Yosef Gavriel Bechhofer: Address the question of how a 12-year-old in a non-religious family can fulfill the obligation of belief, given their lack of independence.