Sunday, March 25, 2007

Middos/Tikkun Continued

To which I now respond: That's an argument??!!

and add:



ספר פרי הארץ - מכתב לז
ובאמת ירדו תהומות ועל אלו אמרו מתריעין מיד בצעקה גדולה ומרת נפש ווי ווי כולי האי ואולי כי נגע עד הנפש:
אשר על כן חרדתי עליהם את כל החרדה הזאת פן ואולי ח"ו תקראנה אותם כאלה, לבנות מגדל בשכל נבדל פן יפתה לבבכם וסרתם מכוונת האמונה והאמת. שכל הדברים הנוגעים ברומו של עולם הכל למקום אחד הולך הוא הסובב אל נקודה אחת הן יראת ה' היא חכמה...



תלמוד ירושלמי מסכת שבת דף ח/ב
ה'. א"ר יצחק בר אלעזר מה שעשת חכמה עטרה לראשה. עשת ענוה עקב לסולייסה דכתיב ראשית חכמה יראת ה'. וכתיב עקב ענוה יראת ה'...



תלמוד בבלי מסכת שבת דף לא/א
אמר ריש לקיש מאי דכתיב והיה אמונת עתיך חוסן ישועות חכמת ודעת וגו' אמונת זה סדר זרעים עתיך זה סדר מועד חסן זה סדר נשים ישועות זה סדר נזיקין חכמת זה סדר קדשים ודעת זה סדר טהרות ואפילו הכי יראת ה' היא אוצרו...

d 







To which my correspondent responded

C'mon there are a million such comments about everything in Torah.
To which I responded:


ביאור הגר"א - משלי פרק ד פסוק יג
חזק במוסר אחוז את המוסר שהתחלת בו ותחזק את עצמו. אל תרף אפילו לפי שעה אל תרף א"ע מן המוסר. נצרה כלומר אלא אדרבה תוסיף תמיד גדרים ומצות על המוסר שלא יבא לידי רפיון. כי היא חייך כי מה שהאדם חי הוא כדי לשבור מה שלא שבר עד הנה אותו המדה לכן צריך תמיד להתחזק ואם לא יתחזק למה לו חיים.


My correspondent wrote:

Staing the position
 
Purpose of Judaism is ethiccal behavior.
 
Talmud trains us in lucid thought.
 
In case we want to think about ethics, Talmudists we will be able to think lucidly. (As well as all other devotees of deamding disciplines.)
 
And then we just might behave ethically.
 
And thats why we all spend a zillion hours on Menachos.
 
You can't possible mean this can you?
 
A gutten Shabbos.

Friday, March 09, 2007

[Fwd: More on Mitzvos and Iyun (Was Tznius and ILG)]



-------- Original Message --------
Subject: More on Mitzvos and Iyun (Was Tznius and ILG)
Date: Fri, 09 Mar 2007 16:28:07 -0500
From: Yosef Gavriel Bechhofer <ygbechhofer@gmail.com>
To: Avodah <avodah@aishdas.org>


My colleague wrote, upon seeing my email:


I think this is a fair representation of my view of mitzvos but I'd like to have "salvific" defined as "metaphysical effect upon the neshamah and upon the spiritual fabric of the cosmos leading to the soul achieving a better place after death."

and

BTW the notion that the minutae of kashrus, taharos, korbanos, ketores, safrus etc ad infinitum has rational overt impact towards our refinement seems to me at least patently absurd.
 
Ditto re the study of Tlamud b'iyun. What difference could it have rationally towards my moral refinement to discuss a stirah in rishonim in zevochim???? Or offer a lmudische disscetion of a machlokes.
 
Either it's all supra rational or its just silly.
 
After reading the Kellner book I am even more convinced of the inability of the neo Aristotelean world view to explain Judaism.

To which I say:


1. I think it absurd to regard all that as salvific. Why would the RBSo have us do all these silly things merely to save our souls. And, a refining impact need not be rationally or overtly explainable.


2. It is only such refining (to both reason and emotion) that makes Talmud b'Iyun worthwhile. See above #1.


3. At least I have the Rambam and Rov Rishonim on my side. Kellner, Shmellner...


YGB

[Fwd: Re: Tzinius and the ILG]



-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Re: Tzinius and the ILG
Date: Fri, 09 Mar 2007 15:32:51 -0500
From: Yosef Gavriel Bechhofer <rygb@aishdas.org>
To: Micha Berger <micha@aishdas.org>
CC: A High-Level Torah Discussion Group <avodah@lists.aishdas.org>
References: <49308.171.159.192.10.1172700363.squirrel@webmail.aishdas.org>


I have an ongoing debate with one of my colleagues at MTA. Were he not Jewish, he would be Catholic, and he believes that a la Catholicism, mitzvos are meant to have a salvational effect on us.


On this basis, he justifies the teaching of Gemara b'Iyun to lower-track students - viz., it has a salvific effect even if they gain little enlightenment from it.


I, OTOH, believe that mitzvos are meant to have a refining impact on us - and that applies even to the most obscure and mystical rites we possess.


As such, I have great difficulty justifying the almost pointless instruction of the lower levels in Gemara b'Iyun. Better to teach them Sefer HaChinuch.


YGB


Micha Berger wrote:

Anyone notice how many of our threads lately revolve around the question of the relationship between halakhah and aggadic moral imperatives? Not that I'm really sure they are aggadic, I think it's more the vagueness of mitzvos about being tov, yashar, and qadosh -- TYQ.  We have the discussion about slavery, the question of whether we are mechuyavim to speak up about the Sudan, or whether such interest may be assimilationism from liberal Judaisms that distracts us from more central priorities, the issue of avaq ribis being close enough to ribis to be wrong but not prohibited...    

[Fwd: Re: AishDas and Mussar]



-------- Original Message --------
Subject: Re: AishDas and Mussar
Date: Fri, 09 Mar 2007 15:25:40 -0500
From: Yosef Gavriel Bechhofer <rygb@aishdas.org>
To: Micha Berger <micha@aishdas.org>
CC: avodah@aishdas.org
References: <mailman.6980.1172552387.25323.areivim-aishdas.org@lists.aishdas.org> <200702271523.l1RFNNN17754@panix2.panix.com> <51341.171.159.192.10.1172594147.squirrel@webmail.aishdas.org>


I have trained my 10th grade talmidim at MTA to think about everything along the Chassidish/Litvish divide, further subdividing Lita into Brisk vs. Mussar. They know my biases, in some cases share them, in some cases reject them (and, to be honest, some are apathetic). I wish someone had let me know about this kind of stuff when I was in 10th grade, and I hope that this "early start" will facilitate their growth in ways that our dor did not acquire when we were in HS.


YGB


Micha Berger wrote:

Mussar is the pursuit of meaning, not a particular answer to the question. This is why Kelm could have secular studies in their high school, while the Alter of Novhardok wrote about the collapse of the Jewish "city" and the need to retreat to the citadel of the Yeshiva. Or the famous distinction between N's "ich been gornisht" vs Slabodka's "gadlus ha'adam".  The only alternative to Mussar is chassidic ecstatic experience. IOW, either one pursues meaning that is based on thought and experience, or one that is based on experience for which thought is a second layer. I chose the former for AishDas. Not the least because the experiential route is already covered by others, but primarily because I'm too into philosophy to be engaged by the alternative.  But both RYBS and R' Yaakov Kaminecki independently discuss the loss of the "erev Shabbos Jew", using the same example (!) to describe the loss of emotional backing to observance.  I highly recommend reading R' Elyakim Krumbein's Musar for Moderns. He relies on sources that reflect the primarily "Anglo" MO community in Israel, ie his typical student in Gush -- RYBS, R' Kook, some Tanya and Likutei Maharan (think ChaBaKuK). The lifestyle he is giving a Mussar foundation to is MO.  Mussar is a broader concept than the one path taken by Tenu'as haMussar. One can use their tools to deepen pretty much any hashkafah. Exceptions might be Bretslov and Izbitch, which eschew any of the kind of thinking which could complicate experience. Probably also Brisk, and the belief that "der bester Mussar seifer iz a blatt gemara" -- no need to attacking Mussar's goals directly.  Just look at the huge gap between my philosophy and RYGB's. I'm into RSRH, REED, the Maharal, the Kuzari, the Aristotelian rishonim. RYGB is citing Qabbalah and Rav Tzadoq. Both of us agree, though, on the need for a head-on attack of the job of becoming the kind of person idealized  In short: I grabbed on Mussar as a tool to work on the heart. It doesn't conflict with the range of philosophies to which one aims that heart.